Reviews

The best ice cream with so many flavors and choices. Plus, the family that runs it makes sure to take good care of you. We come every night we are here, every visit.

The ice cream is still outstanding. The owners are ambassadors for AMI and always have great recommendations for restaurants and adventures. We do indeed go back every day any time we’re on the island.

This place had so many amazing flavors! I got the carmelizer flavor and it was so so good. Definitely recommend going here.

One of my favorite places on AMI! Our family is treated like family every single time we go in. Best ice cream and best family running it, will always be back!

After a bad experience at another local ice cream shop years ago we switched to holy cow ice cream and this business has been a staple for our family every summer vacation since, almost nightly. The staff is just as amazing -if not more- as the ice cream is!!

BEST ICE CREAM EVERRRR!!!! The service is phenomenal and the atmosphere makes you feel like your right at home. I’ve been coming here for years on vacation and can honestly say this would be one of my top reasons to live here permanently.

Absolutely love this place. The family and I have been coming to Anna Maria for over twenty years but have somehow just discovered Holy Cow. It instantly became our favorite ice cream stop on the island. The family that owns the place couldn’t be nicer and the ice cream is incredible. It felt like going over to a friends house for ice cream rather than a business. We will be back!

Amazing family-owned ice cream parlor with MANY allergen & dietary accommodations! Lots of dairy-free / vegan options, including Italian ice, sorbet, almond milk soft serve, and a similar version to Dippin’ Dots! They also have lactose-free soft serve and sugar-free ice cream as well. They have lots of great regular ice cream as well! My son loved Beach Bum, which had caramel, coconut, and generous chunks of chocolate. Yum! The staff are very friendly and personable. They go the extra mile to make sure your family is safe and happy. I wanted to share a picture of our ice cream but we ate it all!

Amazing family-owned ice cream parlor with MANY allergen & dietary accommodations! Lots of dairy-free / vegan options, including Italian ice, sorbet, almond milk soft serve, and a similar version to Dippin’ Dots! They also have lactose-free soft serve and sugar-free ice cream as well. They have lots of great regular ice cream as well! My son loved Beach Bum, which had caramel, coconut, and generous chunks of chocolate. Yum! The staff are very friendly and personable. They go the extra mile to make sure your family is safe and happy. I wanted to share a picture of our ice cream but we ate it all!