About

We are a family-owned business and have been here for 10 years.

Come in and enjoy a milkshake, malt or an ice cream cone made with your choice of the best homemade ice cream. Along with the old fashioned, homemade taste in 36 flavors, we have soft serve, almond milk and sugar free ice cream.

Our Values

Finest Products From Quality Igredients

Our ice cream is homemade from locally sourced ingredients using the most up to date technology. You can taste the care taken to make this ice cream the best.

Vegan and Sugar Free Options for Everyone.

We offer almond milk swirl and a no sugar added ice cream. We also have a no sugar Mini Melts.

Customers Treated Like Family from Ours

When you step into the store, you are greeted warmly and it’s a time to visit before you order your favorites.

Conveniently Located in the Holmes Beach Plaza

Holy Cow Ice Cream is conveniently located in the Holmes Beach Plaza close to Walgreens. We are open daily with plenty of available parking. Come visit us and while you’re enjoying your ice cream also enjoy talking with us. See you soon!

2022 Travelers' Choice Award

 5/5

The best ice cream with so many flavors and choices. Plus, the family that runs it makes sure to take good care of you. We come every night we are here, every visit.

 5/5

The ice cream is still outstanding. The owners are ambassadors for AMI and always have great recommendations for restaurants and adventures. We do indeed go back every day any time we’re on the island.

 5/5

This place had so many amazing flavors! I got the carmelizer flavor and it was so so good. Definitely recommend going here.

 5/5

One of my favorite places on AMI! Our family is treated like family every single time we go in. Best ice cream and best family running it, will always be back!

 5/5

After a bad experience at another local ice cream shop years ago we switched to holy cow ice cream and this business has been a staple for our family every summer vacation since, almost nightly. The staff is just as amazing -if not more- as the ice cream is!!

 5/5

BEST ICE CREAM EVERRRR!!!! The service is phenomenal and the atmosphere makes you feel like your right at home. I’ve been coming here for years on vacation and can honestly say this would be one of my top reasons to live here permanently.